How we rank TCG rip platforms
Five criteria, all about the graded slab, scored only on what each platform says on its own public pages. Facts checked 18 November 2026.
The criteria and weights
The criteria are for collectors who care which company graded the slab. Each is scored from 0 to 10 and weighted. The weighted sum, divided by 100, is the score out of 10. Each platform's sub-scores are on the top five and in the reviews.
Graders named weight 25
10 when the platform names its graders in words. 6 when they appear only as logos.
Graders carried, of PSA, BGS, CGC, SGC, TAG weight 20
2 points for each of PSA, BGS, CGC, SGC and TAG named for the slabs in its packs. Four graders score 8, one scores 2.
Packs by grader or grade weight 20
10 when a pack is sold by grade, such as a PSA 10 pack. 5 when every pack comes from one grader with no grade floor stated.
Grade and cert number at the reveal weight 15
10 when the reveal is stated to show the grade and the cert number. 5 for the grade alone.
Slab shipping weight 20
10 for shipping worldwide or wherever a partner delivers. 8 for a list of countries. 6 for the United States only. One point off where the platform's own pages disagree on the rules, or where storage ends after seven days and each slab ships alone.
When a page says nothing
Where a platform's public pages don't say something a criterion asks about, the cell reads not stated and counts as 0. That describes the pages, not the service. Where another platform matches or leads The Collectibles, the score and the review say so. Courtyard ties on shipping, Card Outpost ties on graders, and Rip Rush and Courtyard have more store ratings.
Sources and date
For The Collectibles we read its Help Center, home page, Packs page and App Store listing. For the other four, their home pages, terms, FAQs, help articles and app store listings. Store ratings and Trustpilot figures are from the same day. Platforms whose pages we couldn't read with confidence are not ranked. Grading facts go no further than those sources and the scales themselves, compared in the PSA vs CGC grader comparison.